Comparing Vision Correction Options

Vision Correction Options: What is Right for Me?

When most patients begin to consider vision correction surgery, LASIK is the procedure that typically comes to mind. However, while LASIK is extremely effective at reducing visual refractive errors, this laser procedure is not always best for every patient. Fortunately, at The Eye Institute of Utah, we offer a full range of vision correction surgery options, including Visian ICLⓇ, LASIK, PRK, and Refractive Lens Exchange (RLE). We are happy to help you learn more about the vision correction options we offer, each of which has distinct benefits for our patients.

Visian ICL

The Visian ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens) is a highly appealing vision correction option, perfectly suited for a wide range of patients who are nearsighted or have astigmatism. In fact, this procedure is often ideal for patients who are not suitable candidates for LASIK and has a 99% patient satisfaction rate.1 Unlike LASIK which reshape a patient’s cornea, vision correction surgery with Visian ICL involves the implantation of an artificial lens implant that is 100% biocompatible and works in harmony with the natural eye. The Visian ICL procedure takes less than 20 minutes and results in near-immediate vision correction and a very short recovery time. The Visian ICL provides excellent night vision, has built-in UV protection, and is totally reversible if necessary. Visian ICL is often an ideal vision correction surgery for patients who are not good candidates for LASIK or PRK, including patients who:

Learn More About Visian ICL

LASIK

LASIK (Laser In-Situ Keratomileusis) is a form of laser vision correction surgery that permanently reshapes the patient’s cornea to reduce refractive errors. To begin the LASIK procedure, the surgeon uses a laser to create a flap in the patient’s cornea. Next, the cornea is minutely reshaped to smooth irregularities that prevent light from properly focusing and cause blurred vision. The entire procedure takes about 15 minutes per eye, and patients begin to notice improved vision within 24-48 hours of LASIK vision correction surgery.

Learn More About LASIK

PRK

PRK (photorefractive keratectomy) is very similar to LASIK in that this procedure reshapes the cornea to correct refractive errors. However, while LASIK surgery involves the creation of a corneal flap using a laser, no corneal flap is created during PRK. Instead, the top surface layer of the cornea (called the epithelium) is removed using a diluted chemical solution. Once the corneal surface is exposed during PRK, the surgeon then uses an excimer laser to reshape the cornea to correct vision. After PRK surgery, the surgeon will place a contact lens on the eye to act as a bandage while the epithelium heals. While PRK does typically entail a longer recovery period than LASIK, this procedure is often a better choice for patients who have chronic dry eye or thin corneas.

Learn More About PRK

RLE (Refractive Lens Exchange)

Refractive Lens Exchange, or RLE, involves the permanent replacement of the natural lens of the eye in a procedure that is essentially identical to cataract surgery. To begin this 15-20 minute procedure, the eyes are numbed with anesthetic drops. A very small incision is made, and the lens of the eye is removed. The surgeon then replaces this with an intraocular lens implant (IOL) designed to improve the way the eye focuses light and corrects refractive errors. Most patients are able to return to normal activities within 2 days of RLE vision correction surgery.

Learn More About RLE

Comparison Chart

See how the most popular vision correction options compare.

 
Visual Clarity
Excellent
Patient Satisfaction
High
Outpatient Procedure
Yes
Procedure Duration
15-20 minutes
Recovery Time
Days
Reversible or Removable
Yes
UV Protection
Yes
Corrects Nearsightedness
Yes
Corrects Farsightedness
No
Corrects Astigmatism
Yes
May Cause Dry Eye
No
Suitable for Patients with Thin Corneas
Yes
Suitable for Patients with Presbyopia
No
Visual Clarity
Excellent
Patient Satisfaction
High
Outpatient Procedure
Yes
Procedure Duration
10-15 minutes
Recovery Time
Days
Reversible or Removable
No
UV Protection
No
Corrects Nearsightedness
Yes
Corrects Farsightedness
Yes
Corrects Astigmatism
Yes
May Cause Dry Eye
Temporary
Suitable for Patients with Thin Corneas
No
Suitable for Patients with Presbyopia
With Monovision
Visual Clarity
Excellent
Patient Satisfaction
High
Outpatient Procedure
Yes
Procedure Duration
10-15 minutes
Recovery Time
Weeks
Reversible or Removable
No
UV Protection
No
Corrects Nearsightedness
Yes
Corrects Farsightedness
Yes
Corrects Astigmatism
Yes
May Cause Dry Eye
Temporary
Suitable for Patients with Thin Corneas
Sometimes
Suitable for Patients with Presbyopia
With Monovision
Visual Clarity
Excellent
Patient Satisfaction
High
Outpatient Procedure
Yes
Procedure Duration
15-20 minutes
Recovery Time
Days
Reversible or Removable
Yes
UV Protection
Yes
Corrects Nearsightedness
Yes
Corrects Farsightedness
Yes
Corrects Astigmatism
Yes
May Cause Dry Eye
No
Suitable for Patients with Thin Corneas
Yes
Suitable for Patients with Presbyopia
Yes
Visual Clarity Excellent Excellent Excellent Excellent
Patient Satisfaction High High High High
Outpatient Procedure Yes Yes Yes Yes
Procedure Duration 15-20 minutes 10-15 minutes 10-15 minutes 15-20 minutes
Recovery Time Days Days Weeks Days
Reversible or Removable Yes No No Yes
UV Protection Yes No No Yes
Corrects Nearsightedness Yes Yes Yes Yes
Corrects Farsightedness No Yes Yes Yes
Corrects Astigmatism Yes Yes Yes Yes
May Cause Dry Eye No Temporary Temporary No
Suitable for Patients with Thin Corneas Yes No Sometimes Yes
Suitable for Patients with Presbyopia No With Monovision With Monovision Yes

Contact The Eye Institute of Utah

When it comes to vision correction, we at The Eye Institute of Utah believe it is important to educate our patients about all available options so that they can make an informed, confident decision about their care. The best way to determine which vision correction option will best meet your needs is to undergo a detailed examination then hold a candid conversation with an eye doctor you trust. To learn more about vision correction surgery and to schedule your personal consultation with an experienced ophthalmologist, please contact us.


1. Staar Surgical. Visian ICL Patient Information Booklet. Available: https://staar.com/file/Patient-Information-Booklet-MKT-0125-Rev-2-9.7.17.pdf. Accessed January 28, 2021.

Request A Consultation X